Anodes are there to corrode. They're the cheapest metal on the underwater gear, wired into the dearer metal around them, and they waste away so the propeller, shaft and through-hulls don't. Once an anode is gone, the next cheapest metal starts paying instead.
How a surveyor checks them
Find every anode: on the shaft, the hull, the rudder, any trim tabs, bow thruster and the engine's own heat exchanger anodes. Judge how much is left. Martyr Anodes' rule is replace at 50 percent worn or at least once a year, depending on the water and use.
Check each is tight, with bare metal under it and no paint on it. Check the metal suits the water. Martyr Anodes lists zinc or aluminium for salt water, aluminium for brackish and magnesium for fresh, and warns against mixing metals.
Then look at what the anodes protect. Pink, pitted propeller edges, pitting on the shaft, or corroded through-hull fittings mean protection has failed or isn't enough.
What decides the grade
Whether the protected metal has started to go. Anodes gone with damage on the propeller or fittings is an A, and the finding asks why. Anodes past half wasted, loose or of the wrong metal is a B. Anodes with life left that will be due at the next haul-out are a C.