Gelcoat is the shine buyers fall for and the first thing the sun takes. On survey, oxidation is usually cosmetic. What matters is how much gelcoat is left after years of compounding, and whether the chalk is hiding cracks.
How long gelcoat lasts
No source gives it a number of years. Quality and exposure decide it.
- Quality. Surveyor David Pascoe writes that most gelcoats have relatively poor resistance to sunlight, with fading and chalking after only a few years. He also notes a high quality gelcoat, Bertram's for example, could still be buffed out and polished decades on.
- UV inhibitors. Practical Sailor says modern gelcoats contain fairly effective UV inhibitors, but they only delay the decline, and gelcoat on older boats may have little or none.
- Where it sits. Practical Sailor notes deck gelcoat has a much harder life, because the horizontal surface takes the sun all day.
- Colour. Practical Sailor warns that colours other than white fade more than owners expect.
A PCI Magazine study of polyester gelcoats describes the order: the colour changes first, then gloss drops as the surface chalks. It names cure, resin chemistry, hardness and thickness as the factors that decide how fast.
How long the fixes last
| Fix | How long it lasts | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Paste wax | Reapply at least twice a season | Yachting |
| Wax in Practical Sailor's test | Needed another coat after four months | Practical Sailor |
| Acrylic gelcoat restorer | Makers recommend recoating after a year, sooner in warm climates | Practical Sailor |
| Paint, done properly | Ten years or longer with care; urethane 15 years or more | David Pascoe |
Practical Sailor adds that restorers are for older, porous gelcoat, at least four years old, and that they can't simply be sanded off later: they have to be removed chemically. That matters if the owner plans to paint.
When painting is the answer
Every compound and polish takes some gelcoat away. Pascoe says that for boats with average or poor gelcoat that oxidises early, painting is the only practical solution, and that preparation is about 75 percent of the cost. Practical Sailor recommends polyurethane for faded, chalky or crazed topsides because of its longevity and resistance to chalking. On decks it warns that painting worn nonskid only makes it more slippery.
How a surveyor checks it
Wipe a hand along the topsides: chalk on the palm is oxidation. Look at the hull in low, raking light for colour patches, and at edges, chines, the sheer and the transom corners, where polishing wears through first. Check the nonskid for grip. Then look past the chalk for crazing and stress cracks, which oxidation can hide.
What decides the grade
Depth, more than shine. Chalk on sound gelcoat is a C. Gelcoat worn through to the laminate, or nonskid gone on a walkway, is a B. It's an A only when the surface hides a defect that needs opening up.