A gelcoat crack is a symptom. The gelcoat is a hard, thin skin, and when the laminate or the hardware under it moves, it cracks. West System's technical adviser Terry Monville puts it plainly: repair the crack without the cause, and it cracks again. The surveyor's job is to say which kind it is.
Reading the pattern
| Pattern | What it usually means |
|---|---|
| A single line crack | Thick gelcoat without fibre behind it, cracked in the mould or by later flexing. Monville calls it part of boat ownership |
| Hairline cracks from a screw hole | A self-tapping screw, or no pilot hole or too small a one |
| Radiating cracks round a stanchion or cleat | The fitting flexes. BoatTEST says the hardware should be tightened, with backing blocks used appropriately |
| A group of cracks running the same way at a corner or hard spot | A more severe problem, in Monville's words: flexing against a bulkhead or another hard spot behind the laminate |
Pike's two questions are the ones to ask on board: do the cracks spread from a stanchion base that flexes, or from a radius that twists in a seaway?
Cosmetic or structural
Pike draws the line at the laminate. Some cracks stay in the gelcoat; others go deeper, into a laminate that is often cored. A deck that feels a little spongy around the cracks suggests a core problem.
Monville's test needs the gelcoat off: remove it, wipe the area with a wet cloth, and cracked fibreglass shows as white lines in the laminate. A surveyor doesn't grind a client's boat, so the report recommends it where the pattern and the sounding point that way.
BoatTEST adds a winter warning: water that gets into open cracks and freezes widens them.