Lightning protection on a boat can't stop a strike. It gives the current a planned path from the masthead to the water, so it doesn't blow its own way through the hull, the crew or the wiring. Florida Sea Grant's bulletin by lightning researcher Ewen Thomson covers grounding and bonding, then the separate problem of saving the electronics. The guidance below comes from that bulletin and from Good Old Boat, which also quotes BoatUS's claims data.
How likely a strike is
BoatUS's figures, quoted in Good Old Boat, put the odds at 1.2 boats in 1,000 struck each year in the US, rising to 4 sailboats in 1,000 in Florida, where most claims occur. Thomson notes that boaters who are struck often say there were no storms in the area just before, because ground flashes can come from anywhere in a storm and slant out from its side.
The grounding system
Thomson's components:
- Air terminal at the masthead, where the strike should attach. With a VHF antenna or instruments up there, he says a separate terminal is highly desirable, high enough that the angle to anything else at the masthead is under 45 degrees, a cone of protection. Good Old Boat suggests at least 10 inches above the mast, pointed.
- Down conductors. An aluminium mast is the preferred conductor, much better than stainless stays.
- Mast base connection. A deck-stepped mast needs a heavy copper conductor from its base down to the ground strips; a keel-stepped mast is connected to the keel bolts.
- Grounding conductors in the water. In salt water a single plate of a square foot or more is usually enough, and a lead keel connected through the keel bolts is adequate. Paint or encapsulation on the keel doesn't seriously compromise it, though it may need minor repair after a strike.
Fresh water is far harder. Thomson says the voltages during a strike are about a thousand times higher than in salt water, and in his sample 40% of protected boats struck in fresh water had side flashes through the hull. It needs a ground strip along the stem connected to the forestay, mast base and backstay, plus extra strips outside the hull near metal fittings such as tanks.
Bonding and side flashes
Bonding joins large metal fittings with mainly horizontal conductors so big voltages can't build between them. Thomson lists toerails, chainplates, steering wheels, engine controls, pulpits and antenna bases. Without it, a side flash can jump from the rig to anything that leads towards the water. Good Old Boat gives examples it knows of: from the forestay to the chain in the locker and out through the hull above the waterline, and from a chainplate to a fuel tank and a through-hull.
ABYC and NFPA disagree
Good Old Boat explains that ABYC downgraded its lightning standard to a technical report, TE-4, which says complete protection isn't implied. NFPA's rewritten standard takes a building-style approach: mast, stays and shrouds joined in a loop at deck level, with several parallel conductors to electrodes totalling at least a square foot below the waterline. Good Old Boat notes there's little data yet on whether that works better, and each boat needs its own design. The ABYC page covers how surveyors cite its documents in a finding.
Electronics
Protection as fitted didn't save the electronics in Thomson's sample: 96% of the 71 struck boats lost at least some. His measures are transient suppressors at each piece of equipment and lightning arrestors on antennas, twisted-pair DC wiring, a heavy copper wire run parallel to each through-hull transducer cable, and disconnecting gear before a storm.
In a storm
Thomson's advice: keep away from the waterline and large metal fittings, and on an unprotected boat from beneath the mast and boom. Go below on a boat with a cabin. Don't get in the water.
For surveyors
Note whether there's a path from mast to keel or ground plate, its condition, and whether the rigging and large fittings are bonded. After a strike, follow the lightning strike damage checks. With Axsail, say "keel-stepped mast, no visible bond to keel bolts, no ground plate, VHF antenna highest point" and it goes on the pre-purchase survey report.