A smell in the bilge goes in the report. Some smells point to a leak that can explode or poison, others to a hose that has to be replaced. The nose is the first instrument: use it on opening the boat, before a pump, a blower or a light is switched on.
What each smell points to
| Smell | Likely source | How serious | Where to look |
|---|---|---|---|
| Gasoline | Fuel leak or spill, vapour in the bilge | Fire and explosion risk | Fuel hoses, filters, tank fittings; see fuel hose |
| Gas (LPG) | Leak at the cooker, hose or cylinder | Fire and explosion risk; LPG sinks to the bilge | Galley and gas locker; see no gas detector |
| Sewage | Permeated sanitation hose, weeping fitting, blocked vent | Health and comfort | Head hoses and tank; see holding tank leak |
| Rotten eggs or sacking | Overcharged, gassing battery giving off hydrogen sulphide | Toxic and flammable | Battery box, charger and alternator settings; see old batteries |
| Musty or stale | Standing water in the bilge | Low, but water is coming from somewhere | Bilge sump, limber holes, deck and hull fittings |
Gasoline and gas
The Coast Guard's guide puts most boat fires and explosions during or just after fuelling. Its routine: open the boat up, run the blower for at least four minutes, check the bilge for vapour and do a sniff test, and don't start the engine until every trace of fuel vapour is gone. Practical Sailor notes LPG is heavier than air and collects low, which is why a gas sniffer belongs near the cabin sole or in the bilge. A bilge blower that works is part of the same finding on a gasoline boat.
Rotten eggs: the battery
In Yachting Monthly, Pat Buckley-Jones describes a sealed lead-acid battery that overcharged and gassed. The smell was less like eggs than "a bit like hessian sacking", and the gas, hydrogen sulphide, "can kill or ignite, and will collect in the boat's hull". It can also dull the sense of smell. The author's advice is an H2S detector, and notes that some CO alarms react to battery gas. Treat the smell as an A: stop charging and ventilate before going near the battery.
Sewage
Practical Sailor's damp rag test finds a permeated hose: wipe the hose with a damp cloth and smell it. A smell with the tank empty and the fittings dry points to the hose itself. The holding tank leak finding covers tanks, vents, hose types and fittings.
Carbon monoxide has no smell
CO from engines, generators and heaters has no smell or colour, so a detector is the only warning. A boat that smells fine can still need a CO alarm finding.